Page 5 of 9

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 20:45
by TC95
tractakid wrote:
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:Doors open at the next station.
But what about, say I was going from New Cross to London Bridge and I start my timer at London Bridge. Is that allowed?
If this is the beginning of the challenge, timer would be started on doors closing at NWX.
They are silly rules in my opinion. No idea how I'm going to get a sub 4hr 30 route then...

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 20:58
by The Orange One
If some of these NR trains wait outside the station for 10 minutes, I will be very cross. Precedent for this has been set in my first R15, when I was 20 minutes down and about 10 of those had been spent on a SWT train between Vauxhall and Waterloo.

In fact, I will be so cross that I shall have the anger of royalty, so I shall be King's Cross. And my rage will be so terrible, it will burn you, so I shall also be Charing Cross. I shall not be Waltham Cross though :lol:

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 21:42
by tractakid
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:Doors open at the next station.
But what about, say I was going from New Cross to London Bridge and I start my timer at London Bridge. Is that allowed?
If this is the beginning of the challenge, timer would be started on doors closing at NWX.
They are silly rules in my opinion. No idea how I'm going to get a sub 4hr 30 route then...
It's the consistent way to do things. Challenge starts with doors closing and end with doors opening. Always.

As for a sub-whatever route, plan better :P

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 22:18
by TC95
tractakid wrote:
As for a sub-whatever route, plan better :P
I constantly amend my routes but only with marginal differences each time

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 22:33
by The Orange One
tractakid wrote:
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:Doors open at the next station.
But what about, say I was going from New Cross to London Bridge and I start my timer at London Bridge. Is that allowed?
If this is the beginning of the challenge, timer would be started on doors closing at NWX.
They are silly rules in my opinion. No idea how I'm going to get a sub 4hr 30 route then...
It's the consistent way to do things. Challenge starts with doors closing and end with doors opening. Always.

As for a sub-whatever route, plan better :P
How about the Nordic Combined? Not quite "Always", is it?

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 22:46
by tractakid
The Orange One wrote:
tractakid wrote:
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:
TC95 wrote:
tractakid wrote:Doors open at the next station.
But what about, say I was going from New Cross to London Bridge and I start my timer at London Bridge. Is that allowed?
If this is the beginning of the challenge, timer would be started on doors closing at NWX.
They are silly rules in my opinion. No idea how I'm going to get a sub 4hr 30 route then...
It's the consistent way to do things. Challenge starts with doors closing and end with doors opening. Always.

As for a sub-whatever route, plan better :P
How about the Nordic Combined? Not quite "Always", is it?
Nordic combined is a substantially different format. It is scored in points, not time. the time is a time limit which expires no matter where you are.

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 23:04
by TC95
I can't remember, did we agree upon a fixed starting station?

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 23:16
by tractakid
TC95 wrote:I can't remember, did we agree upon a fixed starting station?
Not for this challenge. Start wherever you like, though I recommend starting east of Dawlish :)

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 11 Mar 2014, 23:21
by TC95
And north of Ryde Pier Head :D
[I don't think full services have resumed on the Island Line yet]

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 12 Mar 2014, 13:19
by Going Underground
There seems to be a lot of running involved in this...... :|

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 12 Mar 2014, 13:39
by TC95
Going Underground wrote:There seems to be a lot of running involved in this...... :|
Not necessarily. I've got about 4.5hrs with a route that involves no running at all

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 12 Mar 2014, 13:49
by The Orange One
Mine has 3 significant runs. I do not believe you can have a route without running, unless you are pulling off a Fenchurch Street doubleback. Or starting or ending there.

EDIT: Unless, of course, you walk!

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 12 Mar 2014, 15:45
by TC95
The Orange One wrote:Mine has 3 significant runs. I do not believe you can have a route without running, unless you are pulling off a Fenchurch Street doubleback.
[Taps nose] but admitting I don't have the fastest route

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 12 Mar 2014, 18:01
by The Raven
Been doing research today. Though no time as I didn't do Paddington. Still got some valuable information though...

Re: Birthday Challenge V2

Posted: 12 Mar 2014, 18:25
by Going Underground
I have at least 3 runs I have never done before and 1 that I have only done once so is a bit vague and 1 that I know well :!:
Not sure I will be able to do any prior research